ARGUMENT ANALYSIS
Court wrestles with whether a past conviction should bar a lawsuit seeking future relief
Kelsey Dallas
December 4, 2025
Newsfeed
- All Categories
- 2010-2019 Decade in review
- 30 Days of Stevens
- A close look at Judge Neil Gorsuchs jurisprudence
- A Second Opinion
- Abortion regulation symposium
- Academic Round-up
- Aereo symposium
- Affirmative Action After Fisher
- Affirmative action symposium
- Affordable Care Act Exchange Challenges
- Affordable Care Act in depth
- Alexander Bickel Symposium
- Alice Corp. symposium
- Analysis
- Arbitration
- AV Ristorante
- Book Reviews
- Book reviews/Ask the author
- Breaking News
- Brothers in Law
- Capital cases
- Capital Matters
- Cases and Controversies
- Cell phone privacy symposium
- Civil Rights and Wrongs
- Class Actions
- Clear Statements
- Community
- Contraceptive mandate symposium
- Controlling Opinions
- Corrections
- Court Analysis
- Court News
- Courtly Observations
- Courtroom Access
- Death of Justice Sandra Day O'Connor
- Detainee Litigation
- Editor's Notes
- Educational seminars on May 2020 oral arguments
- Election litigation
- Election Symposium
- Emergency appeals and applications
- Empirical SCOTUS
- Event Announcements
- Everything Else
- Explainer
- Featured
- Film Review
- First Mondays
- Fisher II symposium
- Fisher Symposium
- Focus on cameras at the court
- Focus on court reform
- Gene Patenting Symposium
- Greenhouse gas symposium
- Harris v. Quinn symposium
- Health Care
- Immigration Matters
- In Dissent
- In Memoriam
- Interim docket blog
- Judge Kavanaugh's jurisprudence
- Jurisprudence
- Justice Ginsburg dies at 87
- Justice Kennedy's jurisprudence
- Justice Scalia passes away
- Justice, Democracy, and Law
- King v. Burwell
- Kiobel Symposium
- Legal challenges to Trump's entry ban
- Legislative prayer symposium
- List of Orders
- Live
- Live blogs of Gorsuch's nomination announcement and confirmation hearing
- Major Questions
- Merits Cases
- Merrick Garland's nomination to the Supreme Court
- Newsletters
- Nomination of Amy Coney Barrett to the Supreme Court
- Nomination of Brett Kavanaugh to the Supreme Court
- Nomination of Ketanji Brown Jackson
- Nomination of Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court
- Nuts and Bolts
- Obergefell v. Hodges symposium
- Plain English / Cases Made Simple
- Podcast
- Post-decision Health Care Symposium
- Potential Merits Cases
- Profiles of Potential Nominees to Replace Justice Breyer
- Profiling potential nominees to succeed Justice Kennedy
- Profiling President Barack Obama's potential nominees to succeed Justice Scalia
- Profiling President Donald Trump's potential nominees to succeed Justice Scalia
- Race and the Supreme Court
- Ratio Decidendi
- Recurring Columns
- Relist Watch
- Retirement of Art Lien
- Retirement of Justice Anthony Kennedy
- Retirement of Stephen Breyer
- Rights and Responsibilities
- Same-Sex Marriage
- Same-sex marriage and the 14th Amendment
- Same-Sex Marriage Post-Windsor
- SCOTUS bracketology
- SCOTUS for law students
- SCOTUS Outside Opinions
- SCOTUS Videos
- ScotusCrim
- SCOTUStalk
- Special Features
- Statistics
- Summer symposium on Carpenter v. United States
- Summer symposium on Christie v. NCAA
- Summer symposium on Gill v. Whitford
- Summer symposium on Jesner v. Arab Bank, PLC
- Summer symposium on Masterpiece Cakeshop, Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission
- Summer symposium on Trump v. International Refugee Assistance Project and Trump v. Hawaii
- Supreme Court history
- Supreme courts around the world
- Symposia before oral arguments of the 2021-22 term
- Symposia on rulings from October Term 2015
- Symposia on rulings from October Term 2016
- Symposia on rulings from October Term 2017
- Symposia on rulings from October Term 2018
- Symposia on rulings of the 2021-22 term
- Symposium before oral argument in Bostock v. Clayton County and Harris Funeral Homes v. EEOC
- Symposium before oral argument in Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee
- Symposium before oral argument in California v. Texas
- Symposium before oral argument in Chiafalo v. Washington and Colorado Department of State v. Baca
- Symposium before oral argument in DHS v. UC Regents, Trump v. NAACP and McAleenan v. Vidal
- Symposium before oral argument in Dobbs v. Jackson Womens Health Organization
- Symposium before oral argument in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue
- Symposium before oral argument in Fulton v. City of Philadelphia
- Symposium before oral argument in June Medical Services v. Russo
- Symposium before oral argument in Kelly v. United States
- Symposium before oral argument in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen
- Symposium before oral argument in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. City of New York
- Symposium before oral argument in Seila Law v. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau
- Symposium before oral argument in Trump v. New York
- Symposium before oral argument in Trump v. Vance and Trump v. Mazars
- Symposium before oral arguments in Biden v. Nebraska & Dept. of Education v. Brown
- Symposium before oral arguments in SFFA v. UNC and SFFA v. Harvard
- Symposium before the oral argument in Department of Commerce v. New York
- Symposium before the oral argument in Janus v. AFSCME
- Symposium before the oral argument in Kisor v. Wilkie
- Symposium before the oral argument in Lee v. Tam
- Symposium before the oral argument in Minnesota Voters Alliance v. Mansky
- Symposium before the oral argument in NIFLA v. Becerra
- Symposium before the oral argument in The American Legion v. American Humanist Association
- Symposium before the oral argument in Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia, Inc. v. Pauley
- Symposium before the oral argument in United States v. Microsoft
- Symposium before the oral arguments in Rucho v. Common Cause and Lamone v. Benisek
- Symposium on campaign finance
- Symposium on Friedrichs v. California Teachers Association
- Symposium on immigration
- Symposium on Judge Barrett's jurisprudence
- Symposium on Justice Breyer's Jurisprudence
- Symposium on Justice Ginsburg's jurisprudence
- Symposium on lethal injections and Glossip v. Gross
- Symposium on October Term 2016s death-penalty decisions
- Symposium on October Term 2016s immigration decisions
- Symposium on October Term 2016s racial-gerrymandering decisions
- Symposium on October Term 2017s separation-of-powers and administrative-law decisions
- Symposium on one person, one vote and Evenwel
- Symposium on recess appointments
- Symposium on the court's ruling in Bostock v. Clayton County and Harris Funeral Homes v. EEOC
- Symposium on the court's ruling in Brnovich v. Democratic National Committee
- Symposium on the court's ruling in DHS v. Regents of the University of California, Trump v. NAACP and Wolf v. Vidal
- Symposium on the court's ruling in Espinoza v. Montana Department of Revenue
- Symposium on the Court's ruling in Fisher II
- Symposium on the court's ruling in Fulton v. Philadelphia
- Symposium on the court's ruling in Janus v. AFSCME
- Symposium on the court's ruling in June Medical Services v. Russo
- Symposium on the court's ruling in Matal v. Tam
- Symposium on the Court's ruling in McDonnell v. United States
- Symposium on the court's ruling in The American Legion v. American Humanist Association
- Symposium on the court's ruling in Trinity Lutheran Church of Columbia, Inc. v. Comer
- Symposium on the court's ruling in Trump v. Hawaii
- Symposium on the Court's ruling in United States v. Texas
- Symposium on the Court's ruling in Whole Woman's Health v. Hellerstedt
- Symposium on the court's ruling inDobbs v. Jackson Women's Health Organization
- Symposium on the court's rulings in Trump v. Mazars and Trump v. Vance
- Symposium on the courts ruling in Department of Commerce v. New York
- Symposium on the courts ruling in Epic Systems Corp. v. Lewis
- Symposium on the courts ruling in Kisor v. Wilkie
- Symposium on the courts ruling in Masterpiece Cakeshop, Ltd. v. Colorado Civil Rights Commission
- Symposium on the courts ruling in New York State Rifle & Pistol Association v. Bruen
- Symposium on the courts ruling in Rucho v. Common Cause and Lamone v. Benisek
- Symposium on the Courts ruling in Zubik v. Burwell
- Symposium on the courts rulings in Gill v. Whitford and Benisek v. Lamone
- Symposium on the Fair Housing Act
- Symposium on the post-COVID court
- Symposium on the Roberts Court after Kennedy
- Symposium on the Roberts court and the religion clauses
- Symposium on the Supreme Court's "shadow docket"
- Symposium on whats next in June Medical Services, LLC v. Gee
- Term in Review
- Texas Dept. of Housing v. The Inclusive Communities Project symposium
- The Constitutionality of the Affordable Care Act
- The Court after Scalia
- The Court and the Voting Rights Act
- This Week at the Court
- Tributes to Ed Kneedler
- Tributes to Justice Anthony Kennedy
- Tributes to Justice Antonin Scalia
- Tributes to Justice Breyer
- Tributes to Justice David Souter
- Tributes to Justice John Paul Stevens
- Tributes to Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg
- Tributes to retiring Deputy Solicitor General Michael Dreeben
- Uncategorized
- United States v. Texas symposium
- View from the Court
- What's Happening Now
- Whole Woman's Health v. Cole symposium
- Williams-Yulee v. Florida Bar symposium
- Zivotofsky v. Kerry symposium
- Zubik v. Burwell symposium
COURTLY OBSERVATIONS
Morrison v. Olson and the triumph of the unitary executive theory
Erwin Chemerinsky
December 3, 2025
ARGUMENT ANALYSIS
Court appears sympathetic to faith-based pregnancy centers’ argument
Amy Howe
December 2, 2025
ARGUMENT ANALYSIS
Court seems dubious of billion-dollar judgment for copyright infringement
Ronald Mann
December 2, 2025
