Petition of the day

Thepetition of the dayis:

Issue:(1) Whether a court can constitutionally take copyrights to works originally owned and authored by an independent contractor and hand them to a private party by judicially re-designating them works for hire; (2) whether employer under the Copyright Act of 1909 can be judicially extended beyond conventional employment to independent contractors, when this contradicts its common law meaning, binding Supreme Court precedent and longstanding canons of statutory construction; and (3) whether work for hire can be determined based on post-creation contingencies, like discretionary payment, when authorship and ownership of a copyrightable work, including work for hire, vests at inception.