Breaking News :

Elgin v. Dep’t of the Treasury

Docket No. Op. Below Argument Opinion Vote Author Term
11-45 1st Cir. Feb 27, 2012
Jun 11, 2012 6-3 Thomas OT 2011

Holding: The Civil Service Reform Act provides the exclusive avenue to judicial review when a qualifying federal employee challenges an adverse employment action by arguing that a federal statute is unconstitutional.

Plain English Summary: With a few exceptions, federal law requires all male U.S. citizens between the ages of eighteen and twenty-five to register for the draft. A different federal law bars from the civil service (which encompasses most of the jobs within the executive branch) anyone who knowingly refused to do so. The lead petitioner in this case was Michael Elgin, a former federal employee who was fired when the government discovered that he failed to register for the draft. Elgin tried to challenge the law in court, arguing among other things that the law violates the Constitution because women are not required to register for the draft – and therefore can never be fired for failing to do so. At issue before the Court was not whether Elgin is correct, but instead how he gets to raise his challenge. By a vote of six to three, the Court sided with the federal government, which argued that a former federal employee like Elgin must first bring his claims to a federal agency (the Merit Systems Protection Board, or MSPB), rather than a court – even if the MSPB isn’t allowed to decide constitutional claims like his. The Court reasoned that, even if the MSPB can’t decide Elgin’s claims, the federal appeals court that reviews the MSPB’s decisions – the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit – can. Therefore, there is no reason to believe that Congress meant to allow litigants like Elgin to bypass the procedure it created for most other employment-related claims.

Judgment: Affirmed, 6-3, in an opinion by Justice Thomas on June 11, 2012. Justice Alito filed a dissenting opinion, which was joined by Justices Ginsburg and Kagan.

SCOTUSblog Coverage

Briefs and Documents

Merits Briefs for the Petitioner

Amicus Briefs in Support of the Petitioners

Merits Briefs for the Respondents

Certiorari-stage documents

  • Featured Posts

  • Search

Term Snapshot
  • Videos see all


    In this five-part interview, Orin Kerr of the George Washington University Law School discusses his background in mechanical engineering and the law; clerking for Justice Anthony M. Kennedy and Judge Leonard I. Garth of the Third Circuit; working in the Computer Crime and Intellectual Property Section of the Department of Justice; and teaching law. Kerr talks about how […]

  • Peabody Award

    Peabody Award

    Awarded the Peabody Award for excellence in electronic media.

  • Sigma Delta Chi

    Sigma Delta Chi

    Awarded the Sigma Delta Chi deadline reporting award for online coverage of the Affordable Care Act decision.

  • National Press Club Award

    National Press Club Award

    Awarded the National Press Club's Breaking News Award for coverage of the Affordable Care Act decision.

  • Silver Gavel Award

    Silver Gavel Award

    Awarded the Silver Gavel Award by the American Bar Association for fostering the American public’s understanding of the law and the legal system.

  • American Gavel Award

    American Gavel Award

    Awarded the American Gavel Award for Distinguished Reporting About the Judiciary to recognize the highest standards of reporting about courts and the justice system.

  • Subscriptions


    Twitter: Blog Staff Tweets

    Twitter: Each Blog Post, Tweeted
  • Bloomberg Law and SCOTUSblog’s Supreme Court Challenge

    Current Standings - Top 10 Teams

    1. Team SCOTUSblog (4 points)

    2. Baker Nation
         Florida International College of Law (4 points)

    3. Jason Griffin
         Capital University Law School (4 points)

    4. JusticeLeague
         Stanford University Law School (4 points)

    5. I Respectfully Dissent
         University of Hawaii Richardson School of Law (4 points)

    6. In Merit the Win
         Capital University Law School (4 points)

    7. Please Dont Emanate in the Penumbras
         Georgetown University Law Center (4 points)

    8. The Penn Pequod
         University of Pennsylvania Law School (4 points)

    9. Trevor Stanleys Team
         Campbell University - Norman Adrian Wiggins School of Law (4 points)

    10. Moot Point
         Georgetown University Law Center (3 points)

    Click here to learn more